Prison Law Blog

Sara Mayeux

Posts Tagged ‘erie county jail

Latest Ruling in Erie County Suicides Litigation: Buffalo Jail Must Let in Federal Inspectors, But County Attorney Can Come Too

with 2 comments

I’ve been keeping up with ongoing litigation brought by the DOJ Civil Rights Division over a string of suicides in the Erie County jail in Buffalo, N.Y. — the jail has a suicide rate five times the national average, according to the Bureau of Justice Statistics. The most recent issue has been whether the DOJ would be granted unfettered access to the jail to investigate conditions. Here’s the latest update: district judge William Skretny has ruled that federal inspectors must be granted access to the jail facility. But Judge Skretny also ruled that the county is free to send along its own representative — e.g., a county attorney. Prisoners’ rights advocates are concerned:

“I don’t see this as a good thing,” said Karima Amin, co-chairwoman of the Erie County Prisoners Rights Coalition. “With the county attorney standing by, I think employees will be intimidated. They’ll say anything the county attorney wants them to. … Retaliation is real.”

Skretny’s 11-page ruling does not address the issue of whether county attorneys can be present while prisoners are being interviewed. That issue will have to be clarified before the Justice Department inspectors visit the jail March 22-23, according to U.S. Attorney Kathleen M. Mehltretter. …

Many of the people in the jail are young, first-time offenders or others who have never been convicted of a crime, Amin said.

“Any one of our sons or daughters could wind up in that predicament after a first offense,” she said. “I’ve seen it many times. I’ve seen many people whose entire attitude about the jail changes in a heartbeat when one of their own children is locked up.”

Written by sara

March 9, 2010 at 10:04 am

DOJ Lawyers: String of Suicides in Buffalo Jail Is a “Real Crisis”

with one comment

I’ve blogged briefly about the DOJ’s ongoing litigation over conditions in the Erie County Holding Center, the Buffalo, N.Y., jail where several inmates have committed suicide in recent years. Here’s a more detailed report from the Buffalo News:

Justice Department attorneys asked District Judge William M. Skretny to decide as quickly as possible to allow federal investigators to inspect the county’s jail in downtown Buffalo to determine if its suicide-prevention procedures are adequate.

In court papers, Justice Department attorneys refer to the proliferation of suicides at the jail as a “real crisis” that should be addressed as soon as possible.

That statement drew an angry denial from Sheriff Timothy B. Howard, who said there is no crisis at the jail. In a telephone interview, he lashed out at Justice Department investigators.

“I do not believe the Department of Justice has been working with us in a cooperative way,” Howard said. “They say, ‘We want to help you, but you can’t be there when we do.’ They want to question people in our facility without county attorneys being present . . . No other employer would stand for that.” …

County officials deny the allegations, saying the lawsuit is based on hearsay and fictionalized events. [County Attorney Cheryl A.] Green has accused the federal government of trying to force county taxpayers to provide jail prisoners with “the amenities, conveniences and services of a good hotel.”

Written by sara

March 1, 2010 at 10:17 am

DOJ Lawsuit Over Buffalo Jails Is Back in Court Today

with 2 comments

In last week’s Friday roundup I noted the ongoing controversy over a Buffalo, N.Y., jail’s string of inmate suicides. The U.S. Department of Justice Civil Rights Division is suing Erie County over conditions in the lock-up, and the lawsuit was due back in court today. (Erie County has called the DOJ’s allegations “baseless” and its requests for access an “undefined fishing expedition”; you can download the complaint from the DOJ website here.) Buffalo’s WIVB-TV reports:

Erie County Sheriff Timothy Howard said, “Here in Erie County, prisoners are treated not like hotel guests, but citizens should be assured that our inmates are treated firmly, fairly and constitutionally.”

Incidentally, you see quotes like this a lot when you start to follow prison/jail news, and I keep hoping that one day, someone will explain to me where all these jails are where they’re treating the inmates like “hotel guests.” (Apart from Indonesia, of course.)

Written by sara

February 23, 2010 at 12:38 pm

%d bloggers like this: